Ahrefs is the better fit when the gap you need is organic keywords, you want up to 10 competitors in one report, and you can live with a plan article that still argues with itself about Lite credits. Semrush is the better fit when the team already needs Missing, Weak, and Untapped in one table, paid and shopping keywords beside the organic list, and a prompt quota on the same subscription as the SEO tools. Neither Content Gap nor Keyword Gap is an AI prompt gap. On 17 November 2026 Ahrefs' pricing page showed Lite at $129 a month, Standard at $249 a month, and Advanced at $449 a month. Semrush's pricing page showed SEO at $139 a month, Starter at $199 a month, and Pro+ at $299 a month, with lower figures when the year is prepaid. Advanced on that Semrush page was custom.
Last updated - November 2026
I am Austin Heaton, an AEO consultant. The gap reports I am asked to look at are mostly for fintech. The rest are B2B SaaS and a few other industries when the buyer question is the same. A gap tool is useful when I can open the keyword, the URL that ranks, and the position filter that produced the row. It is not useful when the export is a thousand queries nobody will assign to a page, or when someone labels a Google keyword list as an AI citation plan.
Ahrefs' card prices, the annual line, and the feature names I could see are from Ahrefs' pricing page, read on 17 November 2026. The plan-by-plan write-up, including Starter and the Enterprise heading, is How To Choose the Right Ahrefs Plan, by Constance Tan at Ahrefs. The limit tables are What's the difference between all Ahrefs subscription plans?, updated 23 September 2026. Content Gap itself is How to use Content Gap, dated 3 September 2026. The 2023 description of the revamp is What's new at Ahrefs, July 2023. Brand Radar's index, platforms, and add-on rates are What is Brand Radar, and how to use it?. The editor that scores a draft after you pick a keyword is About the new AI Content Helper.
Semrush's card prices are from Semrush's pricing page, read the same day. Plan names and what SEO does not include are Subscriptions and Toolkits. Keyword Gap's labels, the five-domain cap, and the request limits are How to use Keyword Gap. History is Historical Data. Topic Research limits are What is Topic Research. The bundled SEO plus AI product is What is Semrush One?. The older toolkit rates are still on SEO Toolkit Pricing and Plans. Content Toolkit's separate card is Content Toolkit pricing, and the extra boost line is the SEO boost article. I did not create an account on either product. I did not export a gap. I did not publish a page.
The reporting comparison already on this site is not being rewritten as a second invoice. Ahrefs beside Semrush on stored answers, engines, and the prompt meters, from an earlier November read, is Ahrefs vs Semrush for AI search reporting. The toolkit beside Brand Radar is Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit vs Ahrefs Brand Radar. Brand Radar on its own is the Brand Radar review. I am citing the pages I opened on 17 November for the dollars below, not those older tables, even where a figure matches. After a gap becomes a draft, a printed content score is a different budget. That comparison is Rankability vs SurferSEO.
Key Takeaways
- On 17 November 2026 Ahrefs' pricing page showed Lite at $129 a month, Standard at $249 a month, and Advanced at $449 a month, with a header that says pay annually and save up to 17 percent. Prices are exclusive of tax. The pricing article adds Starter at $29 a month, and it says every paid plan except Starter can be monthly or annual, with 2 free months on annual. The same article's Enterprise heading says custom pricing, starts at $1,499 a month, or $4,490 a year. The pricing page's Enterprise cell said talk to sales and did not print those figures. I am not reconciling $1,499 and $4,490 into a monthly equivalent.
- Semrush's pricing page showed SEO at $117.33 a month billed annually, instead of $139 a month. Starter, labeled SEO plus AI Search, was $165.17 billed annually, instead of $199. Pro+ was $248.17 billed annually, instead of $299. The page says save up to 17 percent. Advanced was custom, talk to sales. Free was $0, with 1 demo project and 10 reports a day. The SEO Toolkit article still prints $139.95, $249.95, and $499.95 beside an older limit shape. I am not treating those three rates as the three cards above.
- Ahrefs Content Gap, in the 3 September 2026 help article, compares organic keywords for a target and up to 10 competitors. You can scope an exact URL. Filters cover location, time, keyword difficulty, traffic, and position ranges. Clicking an intersection limits the table to those two URLs. Semrush Keyword Gap compares up to 5 competitors and can mix organic, paid, and product listing ads. Its table labels are Shared, Missing, Weak, Strong, Untapped, Unique, and All.
- The 23 September 2026 Ahrefs plan article lists Competitive Analysis on Lite, not on Starter. A July 2023 post said the newer Content Gap was Standard and above. I am briefing a new Lite purchase from the 2026 article, and I did not click the button. Semrush's Keyword Gap article still gates URL, subdomain, and subfolder comparisons, plus historical data, to Guru and Business. The historical data article adds Semrush One Pro+ or higher as the other way to get that history. Topic Research is two searches per lifetime on Pro, and unlimited on Guru and Business, in an article that has not adopted the new card names.
- AI topic gaps are a different object. Ahrefs' pricing article says no base plan includes the Brand Radar AI indexes. The Brand Radar help article prices a single platform at $199 a month per index and all platforms at $699 a month, and it says chatbot answers in the big index update once a month. Semrush Starter includes 50 prompts tracked daily, one domain for AI brand performance, and 300 AI visibility reports a day. Pro+ raises the prompt line to 100 a day and is the first current card that prints historical SEO data and content optimization. I did not find either vendor applying Keyword Gap's Missing label to a prompt.
What Job Are These Two Reports Doing?
Both reports answer a version of "what do they rank for that we do not." They do not answer it with the same unit, and they do not answer the AI question unless you leave the report and open a second product. Ahrefs Content Gap, in the help article I used, is organic keywords. The target can be a domain or a URL. Competitors can be domains or URLs, up to 10. The article's three uses are new content, a read of a competitor's strategy, and a reason to pitch a guest post. Semrush Keyword Gap is a keyword profile comparison for up to five domains. Organic means a ranking inside the top 100 on Google. Paid means Google Ads in the top 8 positions. PLA means product listing ads. You can point one field at your paid keywords and another at a competitor's organic keywords. That cross-type compare is in the Semrush article. I did not find it in the Ahrefs Content Gap article.
Want AI engines to recommend your company? Book a free 30-minute AI visibility review with Austin.
Book a CallIf the missing piece is "which Google queries should become the next page, because several competitors already rank and we do not," both tools can build the list, inside the caps above. If the missing piece is "which queries are we buying ads on while they rank organically," Semrush's keyword-type control is the sentence I can cite. If the missing piece is "which prompts does ChatGPT answer with their URL and not ours," neither help article is that tool. Ahrefs sends you to Brand Radar. Semrush sends you to the AI Visibility toolkit inside the SEO and SEO-plus-AI plans. I am not going to rename Content Gap because a marketing page says the suite now covers AI.
I care about four objects. The first is the set: how many competitors, and whether a folder or a single URL is allowed. The second is the intersection: missing versus weak versus a keyword only one rival has. The third is the page: can you open the URL that ranks, or only the keyword. The fourth is the next meter: a content score, a topic card, or a prompt report, and whether that meter is on the same invoice. A gap export that nobody turns into a URL is a spreadsheet. A prompt report that nobody ties to a page is a different spreadsheet. The Monday meeting needs to know which file it is holding.
How Do Ahrefs and Semrush Compare?
The table uses the pages I could open on 17 November 2026. Where two Ahrefs pages disagree, the cell says so. Where Semrush's pricing page and a knowledge base article use different plan names, I do not merge them.
| Criterion | Ahrefs | Semrush |
|---|---|---|
| Best fit I can defend from the pages | Organic keyword gaps for a target plus up to 10 competitors, then a separate AI index if you buy it | Keyword intersections for up to 5 domains, including paid and shopping, with prompt tracking on the SEO plus AI cards |
| Price I could verify on 17 November 2026 | Pricing page: Lite $129 a month, Standard $249, Advanced $449. Enterprise: talk to sales. Header: save up to 17 percent annually. Tax extra. Pricing article: Starter $29 a month, and Enterprise starts at $1,499 a month or $4,490 a year in the heading. Additional users on the compare table: $40, $60, and $80 a month, in Lite, Standard, Advanced order. | Pricing page: SEO $139 a month, or $117.33 billed annually. Starter $199, or $165.17 billed annually. Pro+ $299, or $248.17 billed annually. Advanced: custom. Free: $0. Additional users start at $45 a month. The toolkit article still prints $139.95, $249.95, and $499.95. I am not swapping those onto the new cards. |
| The gap report | Content Gap, inside Competitive Analysis. Organic keywords the others rank for and the target does not. Help article dated 3 September 2026. Select the Keywords option. Up to 10 competitors. Exact URL scope is available. | Keyword Gap. Up to 5 competitors. Organic, paid, and PLA. You can set a different type per domain. Intersection labels: Shared, Missing, Weak, Strong, Untapped, Unique, All. |
| Filters that change the list | Location, time frame, keyword difficulty, traffic, and position ranges for the target or the competitors. Click an overlap to see only that pair. Hover a position to see the ranking page. | Database, device, date, position, intent, keyword difficulty, include or exclude words, volume, CPC, competitive density, and result count. URL, subdomain, and subfolder scope is Guru or Business in that article, not every tier. |
| History | Pricing page: Lite 6 months, Standard 2 years, Advanced 5 years. The plan article matches: 6, 24, and 60 months. Enterprise history is unlimited in the plan article. | Historical data article: Keyword Gap monthly overlap back to January 2012 on 9 core databases, December 2013 on 15 more, December 2016 on 89 newer databases. Access requires Guru or higher on the SEO Toolkit, or Semrush One Pro+ or higher. The Pro+ card is the first current card that prints "historical SEO data." |
| Who can open the report | Plan article, 23 September 2026: Competitive Analysis is listed when Lite is compared with Starter. Starter's list does not include it. July 2023 said the newer Content Gap was Standard and above, with the old report left on legacy Lite. I did not click it on a Lite trial. | Keyword Gap is described as part of the SEO toolkit. Request caps in that article: Pro 3,000 a day and 10,000 results, Guru 5,000 and 30,000, Business 10,000 and 50,000. The current cards do not use those three names. I am not pasting the caps onto SEO, Starter, and Pro+. |
| Rows and credits, Ahrefs only | Plan article row caps: Lite 2,500, Standard 30,000, Advanced 75,000, Enterprise 150,000. Credits: the same article says Lite has 1,000 in one table and 500 in the next. The pricing article's limit list says 1,000. Its prose also says 500. Standard and above are unlimited credits on a current plan. Starter export rows are 0. Lite export rows are 500,000 a month. | The current pricing page does not print a Keyword Gap row cap. The knowledge base caps above are the only result counts I could cite, and they use the older tier names. |
| AI topic gap, not the keyword gap | Brand Radar indexes are a separate purchase. Help article: $199 a month per platform index, or $699 a month for all platforms, including 2,500 custom prompt checks. Custom prompt tiers: $50 for 2,500 checks, $100 for 7,000, $250 for 25,000. Chatbot index: once a month. Lite and higher include some custom prompt checks. The pricing page's index line says 572 million or more organic prompts. The help article also prints "over 500+" million and "405+" million. The pricing article prints "over 448" million. I am not picking one. | Starter card: 50 prompts a day, 1 AI brand domain, 300 AI visibility reports a day. Pro+: 100 prompts a day. Advanced: unlimited prompts, custom price. Subscriptions article: Starter's AI coverage names Google Search, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini. Semrush One names a longer list, and not every report sees every engine. The SEO card says "monitor custom prompts," and the subscriptions article says the SEO plan has no dedicated prompt-tracking quota. |
| Turning the gap into a draft | AI Content Helper scores topic coverage from 0 to 100 against competing pages. The pricing article says subscription plans include 5 documents a month, and the standalone tool is $99 a month for 50 more. Free includes 1 a month. The pricing page calls a writing add-on Content Kit, from $99 a month. I did not find a sentence that says those two names are one SKU. | Pro+ is the first current card that prints content optimization. Topic Research, in its own article, is two lifetime searches on Pro and unlimited on Guru and Business. Content Toolkit is a separate subscription. The content pricing page showed Base at $60 a month billed annually, with 10,000 articles a month and 5 SEO content boosts. I did not see a second month-to-month dollar in that HTML. The boost article says 10 more boosts for $30 a month. |
| Seats | Plan article: Lite up to 2 additional users, Standard up to 5, Advanced up to 10. Enterprise comes with 3 and lists additional users as unlimited. Pricing page rates for additional users are the $40, $60, and $80 figures above. | Pricing page: additional users start at $45 a month on the SEO plans. The subscriptions article says the same starting rate for plans that include the SEO Toolkit, and $20 for some toolkits that do not. Content Toolkit's own pricing page printed additional users at $20 a month. |
If the list you actually need is five rival domains in one country, not ten, Book a Call and bring the five domains. The domains show which report is even the right shape before anyone argues about an annual invoice.
The credit conflict on Ahrefs Lite is the cell I would not smooth over. In the 23 September 2026 plan article, the Starter-versus-Lite table sets Lite at 1,000 credits a month. The Lite-versus-Standard table, lower on the same page, sets Lite at 500. The pricing article's comparison list says credits move from 200 on Starter to 1,000 on Lite, and a sentence above that says two additional users join a workspace that includes 500 credits a month. The pricing page's compare block says 1,000 credits per user on the Lite column and unlimited on Standard and above. I counted four prints. I am not going to invent a fifth number so the page agrees with itself. A buyer who will live in Site Explorer all month should assume the smaller figure until Billing shows the larger one. Standard is the first plan the pricing article calls unlimited credits, and the help article says a current Standard plan has unlimited fair use. A legacy Standard plan can still be on a credit cap. The help article tells those subscribers to pick a new plan in the app. I did not see that screen.
Semrush's two ladders are the other cell I would not merge. The pricing page I opened is SEO, Starter, Pro+, and Advanced, at $139, $199, $299, and custom, with the annual equivalents printed beside them. The Keyword Gap article still says Pro, Guru, and Business, with 3,000, 5,000, and 10,000 requests a day and 10,000, 30,000, and 50,000 results. The SEO Toolkit article still prints $139.95, $249.95, and $499.95 next to 5, 15, and 40 websites. Those website counts match SEO, Pro+, and the old Business shape, and they do not match a quiet rename, because Starter is also 5 websites and $199, and Advanced is 40 or more websites at a custom price. $139.95 is not $139. I will not call that a rounding choice the page explained. If your invoice still says Guru, read the invoice. Do not read the Pro+ card onto it.
How Ahrefs Content Gap Builds the List
The 3 September 2026 article is short, and the short version is the one I can re-read. Content Gap sits under Competitive Analysis. You leave the Keywords option selected. You enter a target domain or URL. Suggestions appear as you type. If the comparison should be one page against other pages, you set the scope to Exact URL. You enter competitors the same way, up to 10, and you run Show keyword opportunities. Hovering a position shows the competitor's top ranking page for that keyword. Clicking the number opens the page. That is the whole happy path in the article. I did not run it, so I have not seen how long the table takes or whether a verified project spends a different credit from an unverified one.
The filters are the part that makes the list usable. The upper filters cover location, time frame, and metrics such as keyword difficulty and traffic. The lower filters set position ranges for the target or for the competitors. The July 2023 announcement, which is the revamp note and not the current help article, gave two examples I am not promoting to a 2026 guarantee. One was keywords where your site sits in positions 11 to 20 and at least one competitor is in the top 10. The other was keywords where the target does not rank and at least two named competitors rank in the top 10. The 2026 article still says you can filter position ranges for the target or the competitors. It does not repeat those two examples, and it does not repeat the words "heatmap" or "main positions only." The 2023 post said a heatmap sat at the top and a main-positions toggle could drop image packs and top stories. I am not declaring those controls gone. I am not putting them in a training doc from a post that is three years old. If the screen still has them, the screen wins.
Clicking an intersection between two URLs limits the gap to that pair. That is the control I would use when ten competitors produce a junk list. A payroll product does not need every keyword a media site ranks for just because the media site showed up as a common domain. Intersecting the two real product competitors, then filtering keyword difficulty and a position band, is a smaller list a writer can finish. The opportunities article in the help center says a different shortcut opens Content Gap against the top 10 competitor sites for a target URL, then points at search volume, keyword difficulty, a SERP button, and an AI Identify Intents button. AI Identify Intents is listed in the plan article as a Standard addition inside Keywords Explorer, not as a Lite feature. I did not find a sentence that says the button is removed from Content Gap on Lite. I also did not find a sentence that says Lite includes it. I would look at the button on the plan you actually have.
Row caps will cut the export before the strategy does. The plan article's max rows per report are 2,500 on Lite, 30,000 on Standard, 75,000 on Advanced, and 150,000 on Enterprise, for both verified and unverified in the tables I read. I did not find a separate Content Gap cap. If the report uses the general row cap, Lite is a sample and Standard is the first plan where a broad national gap might fit in one view. Export rows are a second gate. Starter is 0 export rows a month in that article. Lite is 500,000. A Starter user who cannot open Competitive Analysis and cannot export is not the buyer for this job. I am not going to brief the $29 plan as a gap plan.
History changes what "they rank and we do not" means. Six months on Lite is a recent window. Two years on Standard, and five on Advanced, are the pricing page's figures, and they match the plan article's 24 and 60 months. A keyword a competitor ranked for in 2024 and has since lost is not the same opportunity as a keyword they hold this month. The Content Gap article says you can filter time frames. It does not say the filter can see further back than the plan's history. I would not promise a Lite user a 2023 baseline. Enterprise's unlimited history is in the plan article, next to a price the pricing page did not print.
The guest-post use is Ahrefs' own third bullet, and it has a limit the bullet does not spell out. The report can show a keyword a competitor ranks for, and the page that ranks. It cannot place a new article on that domain. When the missing URL is a page on someone else's site, Offsite Posts is a service for getting brand mentions and posts published on third-party sites.
How Semrush Keyword Gap Builds the List
Keyword Gap starts with domains, not with a seed keyword. You enter up to five. The article says the tool will suggest competitors after you enter yours, and that Organic Research competitors or Advertising Research competitors are the other way to find them. You pick a keyword type: organic, paid, or PLA. You can set the type per domain, which is how a paid-versus-organic compare is supposed to work, including entering the same domain twice. You pick a regional database and run Compare. The report then fills a Top Opportunities widget for the domain in the first field, a Keyword Overlap chart, and a table. I did not run it.
The labels are the part worth memorizing, because the widget names are not the strategy. Missing means every competitor ranks and you do not. Weak means you rank and every competitor outranks you. Untapped means you do not rank and at least one competitor does. Strong means you outrank all of them. Unique means you rank and none of them do. Shared means everyone ranks. All is the combined list. Green cells mark the best position in the row. The article's example is a basketball keyword where one domain sits at position 7 and another at 75. I am using that as their illustration of the green cell, not as a ranking I checked.
Missing is the harsh list. Every rival you typed already has a ranking, and you have none. That is a content gap in the ordinary sense, and it gets harsher as you add domains, because five sites sharing a keyword is a higher bar than one site having it. Untapped is the wider net: any one rival is enough. A sloppy competitor set turns Untapped into the other four sites' junk. Weak is the refresh list: you have a URL, and it is behind all of them. I would not assign a writer the Missing export and the Weak export in the same week without saying which one is a new URL and which one is an edit. Unique is the defensive list. It is also how you notice a rival's Unique keywords, which the article treats as ideas, because your other competitors have not taken them either.
Filters do the same job here that position filters do in Ahrefs, with a few extras the Ahrefs article did not claim. You can change database, device, and date. Position can be a custom range, and the article's example is positions 11 to 20 on your domain, which is the second-page list. Intent can be one type or several. Keyword difficulty has six levels in that article. Advanced filters include include or exclude words, volume, CPC, competitive density, and the number of results. The article shows a combined example: a word include, a transactional intent, and a CPC filter. I am not restating their sample CPC as a recommendation. Every filter updates the table, the overlap chart, and the top opportunities. Hover a position to see the URL.
Scope is the gate that changes the buy. The article says you can type a URL, a subdomain, or a subfolder, and that this granular compare is available with a Guru or Business SEO Toolkit subscription only. A team that wants the blog folder against a competitor's blog folder, and not the whole company domain, is not looking at a plan that lacks that scope. The current Pro+ card prints historical SEO data, content optimization, and multi-location tracking. It does not print the words "subfolder" or "Keyword Gap." The historical data article is the bridge I can cite: Keyword Gap history requires Guru or higher, or Semrush One Pro+ or higher. I am willing to brief Pro+ as the history plan because that sentence exists. I am not willing to brief Pro+ as the subfolder plan until a Semrush page says the new name includes that Guru control. I did not find that sentence on 17 November.
History itself is long, and it is not one date for every country. On the nine core databases, which the article lists as the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, France, Italy, Germany, Spain, and Brazil, Keyword Gap's monthly overlap goes back to January 2012. Fifteen more regional databases go back to December 2013. Eighty-nine databases added in December 2016 start then. The numbers are monthly averages, through a date selector. Position Tracking, which is a different tool, keeps daily data for 60 days and then weekly data. I would not tell a client that Keyword Gap has daily ranks for a decade. The article does not say that.
Exports are Excel, CSV, CSV with semicolons, or PDF. You can export a selection, the visible list, or a sized slice. The article lists slice sizes up to 50,000, depending on the report, which matches the Business result cap and not the Pro cap of 10,000. PDF export uses My Reports, and the article says a missing PDF can mean a widget failed to generate. Trials, in the subscriptions article, disable exports even when the paid plan includes them. I would not judge the tool from a trial export that the trial is not allowed to run.
The request caps are the other older-name limit. Pro is up to 3,000 requests a day and 10,000 results. Guru is 5,000 and 30,000. Business is 10,000 and 50,000. A request is not defined as one keyword in the paragraph I read. I will not invent a conversion. A team that refreshes a filtered gap all afternoon can hit a daily request cap before it hits a result cap. Because the current cards do not use these names, I would ask Semrush which cap a Starter login inherits before I put 3,000 in a forecast. I am not putting it there myself.
Topic Research, Content Explorer, and the Draft After the Gap
A keyword list is not a brief. Semrush's Topic Research article is the brainstorm tool: you enter a topic, and it returns cards of subtopics, headlines, and questions, with a location. The article says you can use it to find gaps in a content plan. The limit is the part that changes the plan. Users without an SEO Toolkit subscription, and users on the Pro tier, get two searches per lifetime. Guru and Business are unlimited. "Per lifetime" is a hard phrase. Two searches is a demo, not a workflow. The Semrush One article says the bundle can include SEO Writing Assistant and Topic Research depending on the level. It does not say Starter includes them. The Pro+ card is the first current card that prints the words "content optimization." I would brief Topic Research as a Guru or Business feature from its own article, and as a possible Pro+ feature only where Semrush One's "depending on the level" sentence plus the Pro+ content-optimization line are both in the account. I would not brief it on the $139 SEO card.
Content Toolkit is a different subscription, and the two Semrush pages that describe it do not match. The subscriptions article says one plan, Content Base, with unlimited SEO-friendly articles and 5 SEO-boosted pieces a month that use a deeper SERP analysis, plus a 7-day trial. The content pricing page I opened showed Base at $60 a month billed annually, 10,000 articles a month, and 5 SEO content boosts a month. I did not see a month-to-month price next to that $60. The boost article says the plan includes five SEO-boosted articles a month and that 10 additional boosts are $30 a month. "Unlimited" and "10,000" cannot both be the allowance. I am leaving both sentences in the open. Topic Finder and an SEO Brief Generator are checked on that pricing page. I did not generate an article. Additional users on the content pricing page were $20 a month, which matches the subscriptions article's rate for a content user when the SEO Toolkit is not what sets the seat price.
Ahrefs' path from a keyword to a draft is AI Content Helper, and the help article describes a different score from a term counter. You enter a target keyword, and you can enter an existing URL. You can add competitor sites. You can group the SERP by search intent, or turn that off and pick articles yourself. The score runs from 0 to 100, where 100 means coverage of the topics present in the top pages. Each topic is also scored from 0 to 100. The article says the point is topic coverage, not a required number of times to repeat a term. A chat box can see the draft and the competitor text. The competitors panel shows word count, Domain Rating, and referring domains. I did not open the editor.
The allowance is easy to under-buy. The pricing article says subscription plans include 5 documents a month, the free plan includes 1, and the standalone AI Content Helper is $99 a month for an additional 50 documents. The pricing page, the same day, lists Content Kit from $99 a month and says an AI content inventory is coming soon. I did not find a sentence that equates Content Kit with AI Content Helper. A team that buys "the $99 writing add-on" should read the line on the invoice, because I cannot tell them those two names are one product. Five documents a month is not a content calendar. It is a handful of checked drafts. The gap report can suggest hundreds of keywords. The editor will not write them on the included meter.
Content Explorer is the Ahrefs report I would not confuse with Content Gap. The plan article lists Content Explorer as a Standard addition, next to keyword clusters, search intents, and SERP updates. The pricing blog describes it, with Linking authors, as a way to find publications and writers. That is a prospecting report. Content Gap is a keyword intersection. A Standard upgrade buys both, on the pages I read, and it also buys the move from a conflicting Lite credit cap to unlimited credits. I would not tell a Lite buyer that the only thing Standard adds is "more keywords." The pricing article's Standard list is portfolios, batch analysis, keyword clustering, intents, SERP updates, Content Explorer, and the higher limits. Portfolios start at 100 URLs on Standard and 250 on Advanced, in that article. The pricing page's compare block also prints a "target URLs per report" row. I am using the article's portfolio figures and not inventing a second meaning for the compare-block number.
Where the AI Topic Gap Actually Lives
The AI question is real, and it is not a filter I found inside Content Gap or Keyword Gap. A buyer asks which questions an answer engine covers with a competitor's URL. Ahrefs' answer on its own help pages is Brand Radar. Semrush's answer is the AI Visibility side of the current plans. The comparisons already on this site walk the reporting products at more length. This section is only the part that changes a content-gap buy: what you can see without pretending the keyword export is the prompt export.
Brand Radar's help article says you can benchmark share of voice, mentions, citations, and impressions against competitors, and see cited pages and domains. There is no setup required for the index, and there is no cap stated on how many brands you can look up. Custom prompts are the questions you write yourself. They can be checked monthly or as often as daily. The data note says Ahrefs takes People Also Ask questions from its keyword index and enters them in the web version of each chatbot, in the location of the source keyword, without a logged-in user. Chatbot indexes in that large set update once a month. AI Overviews update every few days. Web visibility updates every few minutes. A monthly chatbot index is not a daily rank tracker. If the board wants yesterday's answer, the custom prompt meter is the one the article ties to a frequency you choose, and the big index is the one it ties to a monthly refresh.
The index size is four sentences, and they do not match. The pricing page says research across 572 million or more organic prompts. The help article's opening says over 500 million, and a later section says 405 million or more search-backed prompts across seven platforms. The pricing article says over 448 million. I am not averaging them. I would put the figure that is on the screen the day you buy into the deck, and I would not put all four. Platforms in the help article are AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, Grok, and Claude. Grok has a note that new data collection is paused after a policy change. Claude is custom prompts only, through an API, on Claude Sonnet 4.6 with web search, and each check consumes 8 checks. No extra add-on is required for that Claude path, in that sentence. The included custom prompts on Lite and higher, in the same article, run on AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Copilot. The pricing article's Lite sentence lists ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, and Claude. I am not deleting either list.
The price of the index is not the price of the keyword plan. The help article says a single platform index is $199 a month, and all platforms are $699 a month, with 2,500 custom prompt checks included on the all-platforms purchase. Custom prompt tiers are $50 a month for 2,500 checks with a $0.020 overage, $100 for 7,000 with a $0.015 overage, and $250 for 25,000 with a $0.010 overage. The pricing page shows a $50 example described as 100 prompts daily on 2 platforms with a $0.015 overage, and a $250 tier with a $0.010 overage. The $50 overage on the pricing page does not match the $0.020 overage in the help article's Basic tier. I am not going to decide which page the checkout uses. The pricing article is explicit on one point I would highlight: no base subscription includes the AI platform indexes. Lite's included prompt checks are not the same thing as the index of hundreds of millions of prompts. The Brand Radar review is where that split is the whole article. I am not rebuilding it here.
Semrush's current cards put a smaller prompt meter on the subscription instead of a separate index price. Starter is 50 prompts tracked daily, one domain for AI brand performance, and 300 AI visibility reports a day, plus an AI-ready Site Audit. Pro+ is 100 prompts a day, on top of the Starter AI block, plus the SEO additions. Advanced says unlimited prompts and does not print a price. The subscriptions article describes Starter's engines as Google Search, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini. The Semrush One article is wider and then narrows by report. AI Analysis reports cover Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, and ChatGPT. Brand Performance covers Google AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini. Prompt Tracking covers Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, and ChatGPT. I would not tell a Starter buyer that all five names are in every report. The SEO card, the cheaper one, says the plan tracks performance in AI search, monitors sentiment, runs AI visibility reports for any domain, and monitors custom prompts. The subscriptions article says that same SEO plan does not include a dedicated prompt-tracking quota, an AI-ready Site Audit, or per-domain AI brand performance. Both pages were Semrush's. I cannot make them one sentence. A buyer who needs a counted daily prompt quota should not assume the $139 card is the $199 card with a different label.
What I did not find, on either side, is a content-gap intersection for prompts. Semrush One says you can benchmark competitors on Google and on AI platforms, and that you can identify new prompts and keywords. That is a capability sentence. It is not the Missing, Weak, and Untapped table. Ahrefs can show you cited domains in Brand Radar, and it can show you organic keywords in Content Gap. Putting those exports in one slide does not make them one metric. A keyword you do not rank for and a prompt that cites a rival's URL can be the same topic, or they can be unrelated. Someone still has to read both rows. The reporting comparison on this site, Ahrefs vs Semrush for AI search reporting, is the page for the stored answer. The toolkit comparison is Semrush's toolkit beside Brand Radar. This page stops at the point where a gap report ends and those products begin.
Who Should Buy Which Report
Pick from the unit, the competitor cap, and whether the AI question is actually the question.
- You need organic keywords, up to 10 competitors, and an exact URL as the target. Ahrefs Content Gap. Lite is the first plan the September 2026 article lists with Competitive Analysis. Read the credit conflict before you depend on Lite for a month of Site Explorer. Standard is the plan I would brief when you need unlimited credits, Content Explorer, 30,000 rows, and two years of history. The price is on the card above.
- You need Missing, Weak, and Untapped, or you need paid and shopping in the same gap. Semrush Keyword Gap, capped at five domains. If the compare is a subfolder, the article I can cite still says Guru or Business. If the compare needs history, the article I can cite says Guru or Semrush One Pro+. Pro+ is the current card that prints historical SEO data, at the annual and monthly figures in the table. I am not promising the subfolder control on that card.
- The calendar is topic ideas, not a competitor intersection. Semrush Topic Research, with the lifetime limit on Pro. Ahrefs Keywords Explorer is the other brainstorm, and it is not Content Gap. Clustering and intent identification show up as Standard features in the plan article. I would not buy a gap tool to do a seed-keyword expansion.
- The board asked which prompts cite a competitor. Brand Radar's index, priced as an add-on, or Semrush Starter's 50 daily prompts if those engines and that quota match the question. Do not export Content Gap and rename the file. The Brand Radar review has the longer version of the Ahrefs side.
- You already know the keyword and you need a draft score. Ahrefs AI Content Helper, inside the five included documents, or a content tool that prints its formula. Rankability beside Surfer is that comparison. A gap tool does not grade the paragraph.
- You need the model fact-checked against a fee schedule. A keyword gap will not do it. A prompt report will not do it unless a person reads the stored answer. On a live account, Austin Heaton still reads the fee sentence before it goes in a deck. I would not leave a generated draft alone on a page that states a price, a license, or a partner.
The consultant version of this choice, if the login is not the thing you want to operate, is a different engagement from a software subscription. This page is only the reports. A query the buyer actually asks is still the object that decides whether the next file is a keyword export or a prompt export.
What I Could Not Confirm
- A live Content Gap table or a live Keyword Gap table. I read the help articles and the pricing pages. I did not create an account, and I did not spend a credit or a request.
- Which Lite credit number the app enforces. The plan article prints 1,000 and 500. The pricing article prints 1,000 and also says 500. The pricing page prints 1,000 credits per user on Lite.
- Whether a new Lite subscription can open the current Content Gap. The September 2026 plan article lists Competitive Analysis on Lite. The July 2023 post limited the newer report to Standard and above. I did not click the nav item.
- A Semrush page that maps Pro, Guru, and Business request caps onto SEO, Starter, Pro+, and Advanced. I am not supplying that map.
- Whether Pro+ includes Keyword Gap's subfolder scope. History, yes, because the historical data article names Semrush One Pro+. Subfolder scope, no sentence I found.
- Whether Content Kit and AI Content Helper are the same $99 add-on. Both names appear on Ahrefs pages at that rate. The document counts are in the pricing article, not on the Content Kit line I could read.
- One Brand Radar index size. I found four printed figures. The checkout screen is the one I would quote.
- Which $50 custom-prompt overage the card charges. The help article says $0.020 on the basic tier. The pricing page's $50 example says $0.015. I did not check out.
- A month-to-month price for Semrush Content Toolkit Base. The page I opened showed $60 a month billed annually. The subscriptions article's "unlimited" articles and the pricing card's 10,000 articles are both still on Semrush's site.
- That any customer result on a Semrush marketing page, or any Ahrefs example keyword, is a result I measured. The basketball positions are their illustration. I did not check them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the better fit for content gap analysis?
Ahrefs is the better fit when the job is organic keywords that up to ten competitors rank for and you do not, with position filters and a row cap you can read on the plan article. Semrush is the better fit when you need the Missing, Weak, and Untapped labels, and you also need paid or shopping keywords in the same report, capped at five domains. Neither report is an AI prompt gap. The prices are in the pricing table in this article. I did not run either report in an account.
How many competitors can each report compare?
The Ahrefs Content Gap help article, dated 3 September 2026, says you can enter up to ten competitors, plus a target that can be a domain or an exact URL. The Semrush Keyword Gap article says the report compares keyword profiles of up to five competitors. Semrush can set a different keyword type on each field, including organic, paid, and product listing ads. The Ahrefs article I used tells you to select Keywords. It does not name a paid mode in the text I could read.
Does Ahrefs Content Gap show AI prompt gaps?
Not on the help article I opened. Content Gap looks for organic keywords other sites rank for and the target does not. AI prompt coverage is Brand Radar, which the help article describes as a separate index, and the pricing article says the AI platform indexes are not included in a base plan. Custom prompt checks that do come with Lite and higher are a different meter from Content Gap rows. I would not export a keyword gap and call it an AI citation gap.
What do Semrush Missing, Weak, and Untapped mean?
The Keyword Gap article defines Missing as keywords where every competitor you entered ranks and the domain in the You field does not. Weak means you rank, and every competitor ranks higher. Untapped means you do not rank and at least one competitor does. Strong means you rank higher than all of them. Unique means you rank and none of them do. Shared means every site ranks. Those labels are Google keyword intersections in that article. I did not find the same six labels applied to AI prompts.
Which Semrush plan includes historical Keyword Gap data and Topic Research?
The historical data article says SEO historical data, including Keyword Gap back to January 2012 on select databases, needs at least a Guru subscription to the SEO Toolkit or a Semrush One Pro+ subscription or higher. The Topic Research article says Pro, and anyone without an SEO Toolkit subscription, gets two searches per lifetime, and Guru and Business are unlimited. The current pricing cards use different names. Pro+ is the first card I read that prints historical SEO data and content optimization. I am not renaming the older articles onto the new cards.
Which Ahrefs plan includes Competitive Analysis?
The plan article updated 23 September 2026 lists Competitive Analysis as a Lite addition, compared with Starter. Starter's own list on that page does not include it. A July 2023 announcement said the newer Content Gap was on new Standard plans and above, and that legacy Lite kept the older report. I am using the 2026 help article for a new purchase, and I did not click the tool on a Lite login. Row caps, history, and credits still differ by plan, and those limits are in the pricing table in this article.
Where do I read the current prices?
The figures I could verify are in the pricing table in this article, with the page each figure came from. Ahrefs' public pricing page and Ahrefs' own pricing article do not print the same Enterprise line. Semrush's public pricing page and the SEO Toolkit knowledge base do not print the same three rates. If a contract is already signed, the contract is the price. I am not averaging the pages into a third number.
Who should skip both tools for this job?
Skip both when the job is a citation guarantee, because a keyword gap is a list of queries someone else ranks for, not a promise that an answer engine will cite the page you write next. Skip Ahrefs Content Gap when the missing object is an AI prompt, and open Brand Radar or a prompt tracker instead. Skip Semrush Keyword Gap when you need more than five domains in one report. Skip unattended drafts on any page that states a fee. A gap export is not a published URL.
Read next:
- Ahrefs vs Semrush for AI Search Reporting
- Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit vs Ahrefs Brand Radar
- Ahrefs Brand Radar Review, November 2026
- Rankability vs SurferSEO for Content SEO
If the keyword export, the prompt quota, and the person who assigns the URL are three different purchases, Book a Call and we will put the query, the report, and the page on one list before anyone renews a login that cannot open the intersection they meant.