SEO Consulting

AthenaHQ vs Peec AI for AI Visibility Tracking in 2026

AthenaHQ and Peec AI compared on credits, prompts, models, citations, and the November 2026 prices each vendor still prints.

AthenaHQ is the better fit when the published plan has to say unlimited prompts, put eleven model names on the paid card, and include on-page and off-page actions plus a content agent, and the team can live with a credit pool instead of a prompt cap. Peec AI is the better fit when you choose three models from a menu that includes Perplexity, the invoice stays on a published monthly price, and the table prints both a prompt cap and a monthly answer total. Neither one is a citation guarantee. On 20 November 2026 AthenaHQ's plans page showed Essential as free and Starter at $295 a month. Enterprise was custom. Peec's brand pricing page showed Starter at $95 a month, Pro at $245, and Advanced at $495. Enterprise was custom on that page too.

Last updated - November 2026

I am Austin Heaton, an AEO consultant. The visibility logs I am asked to look at are mostly for fintech. The rest are B2B SaaS and a few other industries when the buyer question is the same. A tracker is useful when I can open the prompt, the model, and the URL. It is not useful when a team exports a score and calls it a pipeline, or when two pages on the same site still describe two different products.

AthenaHQ's prices, the Starter and Enterprise comparison, and the tooltips under the credit lines are from AthenaHQ's plans page, read on 20 November 2026. I read the image alt text on that comparison. The icons are labeled "has" or "none." The eleven model names on the Starter card are the logos on that same page, and the homepage list is athenahq.ai, read the same day. The response row, including the split between a mention, a source, a citation, and an attributed citation, is from the Responses guide. Cited domains and the rescan credit are from the Sources guide. Oracle's scan rules are from the Oracle guide. The billing screen, which uses a plan name the public cards do not show, is Billing Settings. I did not create an account. I did not run a prompt. I did not export a CSV.

Peec's brand prices, the comparison table, the add-on cards, and the FAQ are from Peec's pricing page for brands, read the same day. The source-versus-mention definition, and the model list that does not match the pricing page, are from Peec's AI instructions page. That page says its prices were confirmed as of July 2026. I am not using those July prices. I did not create an account. I did not run a prompt. Agency pricing is a different Peec page, and I am not restating it in this comparison. The brand cards are the invoice.

The pages already on this site are not being rewritten as a second invoice. AthenaHQ on its own, from a 12 November read of this same plans page, is the AthenaHQ review. The free card, the $295 card, the 3,600-credit line, and the eleven-model logos I could see on 20 November still match that review. I am citing today's page. AthenaHQ beside Profound is AthenaHQ vs Profound. Peec on its own, from a 14 November read, is the Peec AI review. The brand dollars, the choose-three menu, and the 4,500, 13,500, and 31,500 answer totals I could see on 20 November still match that review. Peec beside Scrunch is Peec AI vs Scrunch. Peec beside Otterly is Otterly.ai vs Peec AI. If the quote is the problem and Peec is the tool you might leave, the shortlist is Peec AI alternatives. Writesonic beside Peec, which is a writer plus a tracker rather than this pair, is Writesonic GEO vs Peec AI.

Key Takeaways

  • On 20 November 2026 AthenaHQ's plans page showed Essential as free, with "$25 free credit" on the card and a tooltip that says "Includes 300 credits." Starter was $295 a month. The Starter card prints "$300/month free credit," and the tooltip on that line says "3,600 credits." The comparison row says 3,600 credits a month and "1 credit = 1 AI response." Enterprise credits are custom, with the same one-credit definition. The annual control is labeled "17% off." I did not extract an annual dollar. API access and extra credits on Starter are paid add-ons, and the page says to make contact for that price. I am not dividing 3,600 by 12 to invent a per-credit rate, and I am not treating the "$300/month free credit" string as a discount off the $295 plan. Both strings are on the card. They are not a third price I calculated.
  • The Starter card says visibility across 11 models. The logos under that card are ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral, plus a line that additional models are available on request. That is eleven names. The comparison's monitoring row names eight of them, ChatGPT through Grok, and then says "and more," and both Starter and Enterprise are marked included on that row. The Essential card's logos are a shorter set: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot. Essential does not say eleven models. The homepage also says "11+ LLMs" in the command-center copy. I am not adding a twelfth name to make "11+" into a contents list.
  • Peec's brand page showed Starter at $95 a month for 50 prompts, Pro at $245 for 150, and Advanced at $495 for 350. Each self-serve plan runs 3 models, daily. Monthly AI answers print as 4,500, 13,500, and 31,500. The table says that total is tracked prompts times active models times tracking frequency. The FAQ's example is 50 prompts times 3 models times 30 days, which is 4,500. One hundred fifty times 3 times 30 is 13,500. Three hundred fifty times 3 times 30 is 31,500. The printed totals match a 30-day month. They do not, by themselves, tell me what the product does in a 31-day month. Users, languages, and competitors are unlimited on every column. Countries on the table are 1, 3, and 3. The FAQ says you can track any supported country or language at no additional cost. Both sentences were on the page.
  • The two products do not sell the same unit. AthenaHQ prints credits and says one credit is one AI response, with unlimited topics and prompts, and it does not say how many models one scheduled prompt spends. Peec prints prompts, a cap of three active models, and an answer total. An extra Peec model is $30 a month on Starter, $70 on Pro, and $140 on Advanced, described as one additional model based on the prompts in the plan. The add-on name list is shorter than the menu of eight: ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Bing AI Mode, Perplexity, and Gemini. I did not find an article allowance on Peec. AthenaHQ Starter includes a content optimization agent and on-page and off-page actions. The advanced agent, the Citation Engine, and Oracle are not on that card.
  • The definitions do not use the same words. AthenaHQ's Responses guide has four yes-or-no fields: mentioned, sources provided, cited anything, and cited the content you track. Peec's table has separate rows called Retrievals and Citation share, both marked on every brand plan. Peec's instructions page separates a brand named in the answer from the brand's own content used as a source. Peec's gap list is marked on Starter. AthenaHQ's Citation Engine is marked none on Starter and has on Enterprise. No plan I read, on either site, guarantees a mention.

What Job Are These Two Tools Doing?

Both products answer a version of "did an answer engine mention us, and which URL did it use." They do not answer it with the same unit, and they do not put the same engines on the entry invoice. AthenaHQ's plans page is a free card, one published monthly price, and a custom column. The paid card's story is a credit pool, eleven models, unlimited prompts, and a base content agent. Peec's brand page is three published monthly prices plus custom. The story is a prompt cap, three models you choose, a calculated answer total, and a gap list. If you buy AthenaHQ for a prompt allowance, the card will not give you one. If you buy Peec for eleven models running at once, the card will not give you that either. Self-serve Peec is three active models. The longer API list is Enterprise.

Want AI engines to recommend your company? Book a free 30-minute AI visibility review with Austin.

Book a Call

If the missing piece is "Claude and Copilot, on a price I can read, and I will not negotiate a prompt cap," AthenaHQ's Starter logos name both, inside the eleven. If the missing piece is "Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Mode, with a prompt count I can put in a budget, and I do not need Claude this month," Peec's menu includes those three and the card tells you to pick three, not eight. Claude is the name that flips. It is on the AthenaHQ Starter logos. On Peec it is an Enterprise API label: the cell lists Claude Sonnet, Claude Haiku, Claude Opus, and Claude Fable, each badged API in the markup I read. Microsoft Copilot is the other flip. It is a logo on AthenaHQ's free card and on the Starter card. I did not find the words Microsoft Copilot as a model name on Peec's pricing page. The Bing AI Mode row on that page uses an icon file named microsoft-copilot.svg. The visible label is Bing AI Mode. I am not renaming it.

I care about four objects. The first is the model: a name on the card you can buy, not a name in an instructions page that dates its prices to July, and not a name in a help example. The second is the unit: a credit, a prompt, and an answer are not interchangeable, and a slide that adds them together is a different report. The third is the URL: a mention of the brand and a citation of the brand's own page are different facts, and both vendors' docs say so in different words. The fourth is the next step: a content agent, an action, a gap list, or a note that the login does not publish the page. A tracker that nobody ties to a page is a spreadsheet. A generated paragraph that nobody checks against the fee schedule is a different risk.

There is a packaging note on both sides, and I am dating it so a deck does not mix the months. AthenaHQ's plans page on 20 November still shows the shape this site described on 12 November: free, $295, custom, 3,600 credits, eleven models on the paid card. I am not carrying a second AthenaHQ price forward because I did not find one. Peec's brand dollars on 20 November still match the 14 November review on this site. What did not match, and still does not match, is Peec's own instructions page. That page says prices were confirmed in July 2026, tells you to verify them, and describes a default model set that includes Microsoft Copilot and does not match the menu on the pricing table I opened. I am using the pricing table for the menu. I am using the instructions page for the definition of a mention versus a source, and I am saying the July prices are not the invoice.

How Do AthenaHQ and Peec AI Compare?

The table uses the pages I opened on 20 November 2026. AthenaHQ's annual dollar is blank because the control is a percentage and I did not extract a charge. Peec's July instructions page is not a second column. A cell that says the pages disagree means both sentences were on the site and I am not picking a winner without a login.

CriterionAthenaHQPeec AI, brand plans
Best fit I can defend from the 20 November pagesA published monthly card with unlimited prompts, a credit pool, eleven model logos, and a base content agent. A second country, the Citation Engine, and Oracle are on the custom column.A published monthly card where you choose 3 models from 8, with a prompt cap and a printed answer total. Claude is not on that menu. The instructions page still describes a different default set, including Microsoft Copilot.
Price I could readEssential is free. The card says $25 free credit, and the tooltip says 300 credits. Starter is $295 a month. The card says $300 a month free credit, and the tooltip says 3,600 credits. Enterprise is custom. Annual is labeled 17% off. I did not extract an annual dollar. Add-on API and extra credits: contact for the price.$95, $245, and $495 a month on Starter, Pro, and Advanced. Enterprise is custom. The FAQ says annual billing is 15% off. I did not see an annual dollar on the base cards. One extra model is $30, $70, or $140 a month, with save lines of $60, $180, and $300. Those save lines are not 15% of twelve months of the add-on.
Models on a self-serve cardStarter logos: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral. The card says 11 models. More on request. Essential's logos stop at ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot. The comparison row says eight names and then "and more," on both Starter and Enterprise.Choose 3 from ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE (Baidu), and Bing AI Mode. The same eight are listed on Starter, Pro, and Advanced. Enterprise says choose from all models and up to 26. The cell adds API labels, including four Claude names, Grok, DeepSeek, Qwen, Muse Spark, and others. I did not find the words Microsoft Copilot on this page.
Prompts, credits, answersComparison: 3,600 credits a month on Starter, 1 credit = 1 AI response, one month of rollover on the card. Topics and prompts are unlimited. The page does not say how many models one prompt runs, so the pool is not a prompt cap. Extra credits are a paid add-on with no public rate. Essential's tooltip is 300 credits, and that card does not mention rollover.50, 150, and 350 prompts. 3 active models. Daily on the priced plans. Monthly answers 4,500, 13,500, and 31,500. FAQ example uses 30 days. Enterprise is unlimited prompts, unlimited active models, daily or weekly. Agent credits are a separate row: 500, 750, and 1,000. The table does not say what one agent credit runs.
Mention, citation, and the next stepResponses guide: mentioned, sources, cited, and attributed citation are separate yes-or-no fields. Sponsored ChatGPT placements are reported apart from organic mentions. Sources guide: citation share is not website traffic. Citation Engine is none on Starter and has on Enterprise. On-page and off-page actions are on Starter. The recommendation engine is not.Retrievals and citation share are separate rows on every brand plan, including Starter. Instructions page: brand visibility is the name in the answer. Source visibility is your content used or cited, even if the name is absent. Gap analysis and recommended actions are on Starter. Fact-checked prompts are 5, 10, and 25. The instructions page says Peec does not write or publish the page.
Countries, people, and accessStarter card says country-level support. Comparison: multiple countries is none on Starter and has on Enterprise. Multi-language support reads Single on Starter and Multiple on Enterprise. Seats are unlimited on both compared columns. SAML SSO, audit logs, a 2-hour SLA, and a dedicated Slack channel are none on Starter. CSV export of responses is a paid-plan control in the Responses guide. API is a paid add-on on Starter and included on Enterprise.Countries on the table: 1, 3, 3, then unlimited. The Advanced bullets also say multi country. The FAQ says any supported country or language at no extra cost. Users are unlimited on every column. Projects are 1, 2, 5, then unlimited. API starts on Pro. Looker Studio and custom attributes start on Advanced. SSO is Enterprise. MCP and CSV are on every column. SOC 2 is marked on every column. The FAQ says the Type II report goes to custom-plan customers through sales.

If the eleven-model card and the three-model menu are about to be two purchases, Book a Call and bring one prompt the buyer actually asks. The prompt shows which card can even track it before anyone argues about a credit.

The number I would circle on AthenaHQ is not $295. It is 3,600, and then the fact that the page will not turn that number into a prompt count. One credit equals one AI response, on the comparison tooltip. If a response is one model's answer to one prompt, 3,600 is 3,600 of those. If a single prompt is fanned across all eleven logos, the same pool is a much smaller set of questions, and the page does not say that it is. Unlimited prompts, on the card, means the prompt list is not the meter. The credit pool is the meter. A team that loads a large prompt set and ticks every model can spend the month without an error message that mentions prompts. I would ask, in writing, how many credits one prompt spends when more than one model is on. I did not see that sentence. Rollover is one month, on the Starter card, not on the free card. Unused credits do not, on the pages I read, become a second year's balance.

The number I would circle on Peec is the model count inside the prompt cap, and then the 30 in the FAQ's example. Starter is 50 prompts on 3 models. The FAQ says one AI answer is one chat result per model, and it walks 50 times 3 times 30 as 4,500. That is the number printed in the table. Pro is 150 times 3 times 30, which is 13,500. Advanced is 350 times 3 times 30, which is 31,500. The arithmetic fits a 30-day month and three models every day. It does not fit a reading where you track 50 prompts on one model and keep the other two in reserve at no cost to the answer total. Active models are 3 on every priced plan. If you use fewer than three, I did not find a sentence that refunds the unused model into more prompts. The add-on is how you get a fourth: $30, $70, or $140 a month, one model, and the name list on that add-on drops Naver and ERNIE. A fourth model that is not on the add-on list is a question for the account, not a box I can check from the page.

Countries are the procurement cell that will start an argument, on both sites. AthenaHQ's Starter card says country-level support. The comparison then marks Multiple Countries as none on Starter and has on Enterprise, and it marks multi-language and multi-region support as Single versus Multiple. I am not going to delete the icon to make the card's "country-level" line mean "as many countries as you want." Country-level can mean the product can store a country. It can also mean one country. The icon says the multiple is Enterprise. Peec's table says 1 country on Starter and 3 on Pro and Advanced. The FAQ on the same page says you can track any supported country or language at no additional cost, and that pricing stays tied to prompts rather than regions. The Advanced bullets say multi country, which matches a cap of 3 better than it matches unlimited. I would put the table's country number in the contract and ask sales to reconcile the FAQ in writing. I am not going to brief either entry plan as "global" because a sentence used the word country.

What AthenaHQ Includes at the Price on the Card

Essential is the free card, and it is not a thin version of the eleven-model product. The lines I could read are unlimited users, prompt and response analysis, sources and competitor insights, content recommendations, and an Athena AI agent. The credit tooltip says 300 credits. The card says $25 free credit. The logos are five, not eleven. I did not find a prompt cap, a country cap, or a rollover sentence on that card. The comparison table underneath is Starter against Enterprise. It is not an Essential column. I would not tell a founder that the free tier "includes everything except the higher limits." The icons I could score are on the paid comparison, and several of them are none on Starter. Essential is a smaller story than that. I did not start the free account, so I cannot tell you whether the five logos are the models that actually run.

Starter at $295 a month is the only published monthly price. The card lists one month of credit rollover, visibility across 11 models, unlimited topics and prompts, unlimited competitors, country-level support, integrations, CSV export, on-page and off-page actions, a content optimization agent, and self-learning content improvement. API access and extra credits are on the card as paid add-ons, with a note to contact for the price. The comparison makes the same split in icons. Additional credits and API are paid add-ons on Starter and included, or included in the custom allocation, on Enterprise. Topics are unlimited on both. Prompt volume estimation is marked numerical on both, with an example that uses a placeholder rather than a real count. I am not inventing the search volume.

The icons that change at Enterprise are the ones a security review usually asks about. Multiple countries, the Athena Citation Engine, the advanced content optimization agent, and a certified specialist are none on Starter and has on Enterprise. Configurable multi-views, a tailored instance, and the executive dashboard with Tableau, Power BI, and Looker are the same split. Persona targeting and the recommendation engine are none, then has. Brand voice, on-page and off-page actions, a smart robots.txt and llms.txt control, citation intelligence, and the base content optimization agent are has on both. Unlimited seats are on both. Google and Microsoft sign-in are on both. A dedicated Slack channel, SAML SSO, audit logs, a 2-hour SLA, white-glove setup, and the specialist are none on Starter. The Enterprise card itself, above the comparison, lists Knowledge Base and claim review, Oracle discrepancy detection, the Citation Engine, SAML and OIDC, an audit log, multi-region and multi-language support, persona targeting, the recommendation engine, the executive dashboard, white-glove setup, and custom credits, websites, and access controls. I did not book the sales call. If a quote adds a country or SSO without naming Enterprise, the quote should say so. The public icons do not.

The homepage is wider than the invoice, and I am keeping it in its place. Ask Athena, in the homepage FAQ, is described as an agent you question in plain language about the account's own prompt, citation, and competitor data. The example questions are about a competitor ranking above you on ChatGPT, and about content gaps on Perplexity. The FAQ contrasts it with ChatGPT by saying the agent is trained on the account's data. I did not type a question into it. A stored run is still only as good as the prompt list and the models that ran. The same homepage prints a Gartner line, 50 percent of traditional search traffic replaced with generative AI by 2028. I did not open the Gartner report. A prediction on a vendor homepage is not a forecast for a client's category. Case-study tiles on the site include percentages I am not using. The page does not show the prompt set, the date range, or the baseline next to those tiles in a way I could recompute.

The billing guide is the page that introduces a plan name the cards do not sell. It says the subscription summary shows the current tier, and it gives the examples Starter, Growth, and Enterprise. The plans page I opened has Essential, Starter, and Enterprise. I did not find a Growth price, a Growth credit count, or a Growth feature list on that page. I am not going to invent one. If the app still shows a Growth tier for an older subscription, the invoice is the tier. This review cannot see that invoice. The guide also describes a shared organization credit pool, a per-website balance, a daily usage chart, a credit log whose actions include a prompt run and a rescan, and a Stripe link for an open invoice. It says extra credit packages can be managed from the billing dialog. It does not print the package price. That matches the plans page, which says contact us. I did not open the dialog.

Oracle is documented, and it is not a Starter feature on the card. The guide says Oracle checks what models say against verified Knowledge Base facts. A scan needs Oracle access, a website admin, at least 25 verified facts, and one completed prompt run. You do not pick a date range. The scan uses the latest completed prompt run. One scan can run at a time. Acknowledging a finding does not change what the model says. The results the guide names are an inaccuracy share, responses scanned, priority findings, Knowledge Base issues, and disagreements between models. The Enterprise card is where "Oracle discrepancy detection" and "Knowledge Base and claim review" are listed. They are not on the Starter card. I would not buy the $295 plan for that scan and then discover the icon was none.

Two badges should not migrate into a client report. The plans page prints a G2 High Performer line for Spring 2026 in Answer Engine Optimization, and a Slashdot Most Loved Software line at 4.9 out of 5. I did not open G2 or Slashdot and recount the reviews. A badge on a pricing page is a badge on a pricing page. It does not tell you whether the cited URL is stored.

What Peec AI Includes at a Published Price

Starter at $95 a month is the card for a team that can live inside 50 prompts, 3 models, 1 country on the table, and 1 project. The included lines that do not get more expensive as you climb are the ones I would not make a reason to upgrade: unlimited users, unlimited languages, unlimited competitors, daily tracking, brand context, prompt suggestions, personas, bulk import, sub-brand tracking, branded versus non-branded classification, intent classification, a visibility overview, an ads library, local GEO, a product catalog upload, SKU-level shopping metrics, domain and URL detail, retrievals, citation share, source classification, gap analysis, recommended actions, agent actions, a crawlability audit, AI referrals, MCP, and CSV. That is a long included list. It is still a 50-prompt list. Fifty questions will not cover branded questions, competitor questions, and the problem questions a buyer actually types, across three models, in more than a sample. The answer total of 4,500 is what three models and a 30-day example do with those 50. It is not 4,500 different questions.

Pro at $245 is the step that changes the prompt cap to 150, countries on the table to 3, projects to 2, and turns the API on. Objections, which are absent on Starter, become monthly. Fact-checked prompts go from 5 to 10. Facts per brand go from 5 to 20. Agent credits go from 500 to 750. Crawl insights go from 4.5 million bot visits to 13.5 million. Active models stay at 3. Looker Studio stays off. Custom attributes stay off. Advanced at $495 is 350 prompts, 3 countries on the table, 5 projects, and the card's own bullet says multi country and Looker Studio. Custom attributes turn on. Objections become weekly. Fact-checked prompts are 25. Facts per brand are 50. Agent credits are 1,000. Crawl insights are 31.5 million bot visits. The Data Studio connector is marked on Advanced, which is the same column as Looker Studio. I am not treating those as two products until a login shows two connectors. SSO stays off until Enterprise. Active models stay at 3.

The crawl-insight caps sit on a number I can check and a rule I cannot. Four thousand five hundred times 1,000 is 4.5 million. Thirteen thousand five hundred times 1,000 is 13.5 million. Thirty-one thousand five hundred times 1,000 is 31.5 million. The bot-visit allowances are one thousand times the monthly answer totals. That can be a formula. It can be a coincidence of how the table was filled in. The page does not say "1,000 bot visits per AI answer." I am showing the arithmetic. I am not promoting it to a policy. A bot visit is also not an answer. The table already separates them into different rows. I would not add 4.5 million to 4,500 and call it reach.

Enterprise is custom, and the model cell is the reason a buyer books the call. The card says choose from all models, unlimited prompts, unlimited projects, daily or weekly, API access, SSO, up to 26 LLM models, and a SOC 2 Type II report on request. The comparison cell repeats the eight self-serve names and then lists more, badged API in the markup: OpenAI Luna, Qwen, Perplexity API, Gemini Search, Claude Sonnet, Claude Haiku, Claude Opus, Claude Fable, DeepSeek, Muse Spark, Meta Wonder, Grok, Mistral Small, Mistral Medium, OpenAI Astra, OpenAI Sol, OpenAI Terra, and Exa. I count eight plus eighteen, which is twenty-six labels, and the card says up to 26. I am counting labels on the page. I am not deciding that Perplexity and Perplexity API are two products, or that Gemini and Gemini Search are one. The cell prints both. Claude is four labels, not a single "Claude" switch. A buyer who needs Claude Sonnet should read the word Sonnet on the order form. The self-serve menu does not include it.

The add-on save lines are a smaller version of the same annual problem. The FAQ says annual billing is 15 percent off. The add-on cards print $30, $70, and $140 a month, and save lines of $60, $180, and $300. Twelve times $30 is $360. Fifteen percent of $360 is $54, not $60. Twelve times $70 is $840. Fifteen percent is $126, not $180. Twelve times $140 is $1,680. Fifteen percent is $252, not $300. If the save line is the discount for paying annually, it is larger than 15 percent of the monthly run rate. If the 15 percent applies only to the base plan, the FAQ does not say "base plan only." I did not flip the annual control, so I did not see the charge replace the monthly price. I would read the billing screen. I would not average $54 and $60 into a number the page does not print.

The instructions page is the definition page, and it is the wrong invoice. It says Peec measures how a brand is described and which sources show up, and that it does not write or publish content. It says a chat is one prompt, on one model, from one location, on one day. It separates brand visibility, the name in the answer, from source visibility, the brand's content used or cited even when the name never appears. That split is the one I can use. The same page says the default engines include ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot, with other names as upgrades. The pricing table I opened does not list Microsoft Copilot, and it does list Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE, and Bing AI Mode on the self-serve menu. The page also prints July 2026 prices and a funding figure. The pricing page says trusted by 4,000-plus brands and agencies. I am not using the funding line or the 4,000. A funding line is not a feature, and a count I did not audit is not a result. Customer quotes on the pricing page include a 5x traffic claim and a line about ranking for prompts within 24 hours. I am not using them. The page does not show the prompt set.

Agent credits are the word that will get copied into the wrong spreadsheet. The brand table lists 500, 750, and 1,000, and it does not say what one credit runs. The instructions page uses credit for a different object, on agency plans: one prompt, on one model, for one day, and it says those credits are an allocation that does not reset. I did not re-open the agency pricing page on 20 November, so I am not restating an agency dollar. I am saying the word credit on the brand card and the word credit in the agency explanation are not safe to add together. Copying 500 agent credits into a forecast that thinks a credit is a prompt-day will produce a number the brand table does not mean. I did not see the agent spend a credit.

Mentions, Citations, and the Page You Do Not Own

This is the section I would make a team read before they buy either login for "AI visibility" as one number. AthenaHQ's Responses guide is the more explicit row. Mentioned is yes or no for the tracked brand. Sources is yes or no for whether the response provided citable sources. Cited is yes or no for whether it cited anything. Attributed citation is yes or no for whether it cited the content you are tracking. Those four can disagree. A response can mention you and cite a competitor. A response can cite your URL and not say the brand name in the prose. Market position is a numeric rank. Sentiment is positive, neutral, negative, or not analyzed. Sponsored ChatGPT placements are reported separately and do not count as organic mentions or citations. If an advertiser also appears in the answer text, only the organic occurrence counts toward the organic metrics, on that guide. I did not open a stored answer, so this is the guide, not a file I downloaded. CSV export is on the same page, and the guide says the button is limited to paid plans. Essential is the free plan. I would not promise a free-tier CSV.

The Sources guide then groups the URLs. Citation percentage is the share of AI responses, under the current filters, that include at least one citation to that domain or URL. Responses influenced is the count. Brand mention percentage, on the domain view, is how often your brand is also mentioned in the responses that cite that source. Monthly impressions are an estimate from citation percentage times estimated prompt volume, and the guide says this is not measured website traffic. Source types are owned, competitor, partner, and third party. Page view adds whether the source page itself mentions the brand, which the guide says can miss a mention in a comment. A bulk rescan of those URLs is a different, smaller credit charge: about 1 credit per 10 URLs, up to 10,000 URLs in a run, and the dialog shows the cost before you confirm. I did not run it. One credit per ten URLs is not the same object as one credit per AI response. Both sentences are in AthenaHQ's own docs. A Monday slide that says "credits" has to say which action spent them.

Peec's table draws a related line with different nouns. Retrievals and citation share are both included on Starter. The instructions page's chat definition says the product stores the model, the response text, every brand mentioned and its order, and every URL the AI accessed or cited. Accessed and cited are both in that sentence. The later definition is cleaner: brand visibility is the name, source visibility is the content, and a brand can be cited often while rarely named, or named often while rarely cited. I am not going to pretend Peec's "citation share" cell is the same object as AthenaHQ's attributed-citation flag until I have opened both rows. Similar words are how a quarterly report goes wrong. If the slide says "citations," it has to say which vendor's definition, and whether the URL was the brand's.

The fix list is gated differently, and neither gate is a published article on the domain that got cited. AthenaHQ includes on-page and off-page actions and a base content agent on Starter. It does not include the Citation Engine, the recommendation engine, or the advanced content agent on that plan. The Sources guide tells you to look at third-party sites that AI already cites, and it says getting the brand mentioned there is one way to influence answers. The guide does not say the login publishes that mention. Peec includes the gap list on Starter: sources that appear often and name competitors but not you. Recommended actions are grouped by earned and owned. Agent actions are generated from your data. The instructions page says the product does not write or publish the content. A generated action and a published URL are different objects. I would not put either tool in a statement of work as the system that places the article.

When the cited URL is a third-party article the tracker cannot place, Offsite Posts writes and publishes industry articles about a brand on other sites, and the site says the posts, mentions, and links in a package are guaranteed while rankings, traffic, and AI mentions are not.

Shopping and ads are easy to over-assign. Peec marks an ads library, a product catalog upload, and SKU-level shopping metrics on every brand plan, including Starter. I did not connect a catalog. AthenaHQ's Responses guide separates sponsored ChatGPT placements from organic metrics. I did not find a shopping row on the AthenaHQ comparison table I scored. I would not tell a Starter buyer at either vendor that they bought a retail report because a feature name includes shopping or ads, and I would not tell them ads tracking is a substitute for opening the answer.

Crawl data should not be merged into the prompt report either. Peec includes a crawlability audit against 40-plus bots on every brand plan, and it meters crawl insights in the millions of bot visits. AthenaHQ's Starter comparison includes a control for AI crawler access through robots.txt and llms.txt, and GA4 and Search Console on both compared columns. A bot that fetched a URL is not an answer that cited it. A referral is not a mention. The Responses guide also says location, as distinct from country, is only available for accounts with the location offering. I did not find a price for that offering. I would ask before I put a city in the prompt plan.

Who Should Buy Which

Pick from the model, the unit, and the person who reads the answer.

  • You need Claude, Copilot, Grok, and a long model list on a published monthly price, and you can accept a credit pool. AthenaHQ Starter, if 3,600 credits and one country, in the sense the comparison icon allows, can hold the month. Read the credit question before you assume eleven logos means eleven runs of every prompt. The free card is not that list. The AthenaHQ review is the 12 November picture. This page is the later read of the same cards.
  • You need a prompt cap, Perplexity, and a printed answer total, and you do not need Claude in that price. Peec Starter, if 50 prompts and 3 models are enough to learn the report. Pro is the first card with the API and 3 countries on the table. Do not buy Peec's entry plan for Copilot. I did not find that name on the pricing page. Do not buy it for Claude. Claude is the Enterprise cell.
  • You need the FAQ and the pricing table to describe the same country rule. They do not, on Peec's brand page. Use the table for 1 and 3, and treat the "no additional cost" FAQ as a sentence that has not been reconciled with the table. AthenaHQ's card says country-level, and the icon says multiple countries are Enterprise. I am not picking the friendlier sentence on either site.
  • You need the login to draft and publish the page. Neither pricing table sells a counted article allowance. AthenaHQ Starter includes a content agent and actions. Peec's instructions page says it does not write or publish. The Writesonic comparison is the neighboring invoice if the article cap is the actual requirement. I am not rebuilding that writer's price here.
  • You need a second country, SSO, or Oracle before a sales conversation. Those are Enterprise cells on the AthenaHQ comparison. Peec's second and third country are on Pro, on the table, and SSO is still Enterprise. The Scrunch comparison is the wider menu if a different entry plan is the actual shortlist. I am not rebuilding Scrunch's invoice here.
  • You need the model checked against a fee schedule. Peec caps fact-checked prompts at 5, 10, and 25. AthenaHQ's Oracle scan is not on the Starter card, and acknowledging a finding does not change the model. On a live account, Austin Heaton still opens the stored answer before a citation rate goes into a deck. Neither cap does that read for you.

A tool subscription and an engagement are different bills. This page is only the tool. Prices on the earlier reviews are not a substitute for the two pricing URLs I opened on 20 November. Where those reviews and these cards still match, I have said so.

What I Could Not Confirm

  • A stored answer inside either product. I read the public pages. I did not create an AthenaHQ account, and I did not start a Peec checkout.
  • How many AthenaHQ credits one prompt spends when more than one model is selected. The comparison says 1 credit equals 1 AI response. It does not say how many responses one prompt creates. I will not convert 3,600 into a prompt allowance.
  • An annual dollar for AthenaHQ. The control says 17% off. I did not extract a charge. An annual dollar for Peec's base plans. The FAQ says 15% off. The add-on save lines do not equal 15% of twelve monthly payments. I did not flip the control.
  • Whether Peec's country FAQ or Peec's country row is what the account enforces. Both are on the pricing page. The table says 1, 3, and 3. The FAQ says no additional cost.
  • Whether the Bing AI Mode row on Peec tracks Bing, Copilot, or both. The visible label is Bing AI Mode. The icon file is named microsoft-copilot.svg. The words Microsoft Copilot do not appear as a model name in the pricing HTML I searched. The instructions page still lists Copilot in a default set.
  • What one Peec agent credit runs, and what a bulk AthenaHQ rescan costs in dollars. The rescan guide says about 1 credit per 10 URLs. It does not print a dollar. The agent-credit row does not print a unit.
  • A Growth plan at AthenaHQ. The billing guide uses the name as an example. The plans page does not show the card.
  • The customer logos, the 4,000-plus line, the G2 and Slashdot badges, the Gartner sentence, and the testimonial percentages. They are on the pages. I am not using them as outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is the better fit for AI visibility tracking?

AthenaHQ is the better fit when the published plan has to say unlimited prompts, name eleven models on the paid card, and include on-page and off-page actions plus a content agent, and you can live with a credit pool instead of a prompt cap. Peec AI is the better fit when you choose three models from a menu that includes Perplexity and the pricing table prints a prompt cap and a monthly answer total. Neither tool promises a citation. The prices, the credits, and the prompt caps are in the pricing table in this article. I did not create an account on either product.

Which engines can I name before a sales call?

AthenaHQ's Starter card says visibility across eleven models, and the logos on that card name ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral, plus a line that more are available on request. The comparison row names eight of them and then says and more. The free card's logos are a shorter set and do not include that eleven. Peec's brand table lets you choose three models from ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE, and Bing AI Mode. Claude and a longer API list are on the Enterprise cell. Peec's instructions page names Microsoft Copilot in a default set and dates its prices to July 2026. I am using the pricing table for the menu, not the older instructions list.

How do prompts and credits compare?

AthenaHQ's comparison says one credit equals one AI response, and it prints a monthly credit count on Starter with one month of rollover. It also says topics and prompts are unlimited. It does not say how many models one scheduled prompt runs, so I will not convert the pool into a prompt allowance. Peec's table prints a prompt cap, three active models, and daily tracking, and it prints a monthly answer total it says is prompts times models times frequency. A FAQ example multiplies prompts, models, and thirty days. The two products are not counting the same object. Those caps are in the pricing table in this article. I did not run a prompt.

Does either tool write or publish the page?

AthenaHQ's Starter card includes a content optimization agent and on-page and off-page actions. The comparison marks the advanced content agent, the recommendation engine, and the Citation Engine as not included on Starter. Peec's pricing table has no article allowance. Peec's instructions page says the product measures visibility and surfaces sources, and that it does not write or publish the content itself. I did not generate a page in either login. A target list is not a published URL.

How does each one define a mention and a citation?

AthenaHQ's Responses guide separates whether the brand was mentioned, whether the response provided sources, whether it cited anything, and whether it cited the content you track. Sponsored ChatGPT placements are reported apart from organic mentions and citations. Peec's brand table has separate rows for retrievals and citation share. Peec's instructions page separates brand visibility, which is the name in the answer, from source visibility, which is the brand's own content used or cited. I did not open a stored answer in either product, so I have not checked the definitions against a live row.

Where do I read the current prices?

The figures I could verify are in the pricing table in this article, with the page each figure came from. AthenaHQ's plans page showed a monthly price on Starter and labeled the annual control as a percentage off. I did not extract an annual dollar. Peec's brand cards show a monthly rate, and the FAQ says annual billing is discounted. Add-on cards print a yearly save line that does not match that percentage against twelve months of the monthly add-on. If a contract is already signed, the contract is the price.

Can I add another country or another model on the entry plan?

AthenaHQ's Starter card says country-level support. The comparison marks multiple countries as not included on Starter and included on Enterprise, and it marks multi-language support as single on Starter. Peec's entry plan is three active models, chosen from the menu, and the comparison table prints one country. An additional-model add-on is a separate card, and its name list is shorter than the menu of eight. The same page's FAQ says country and language do not add to the price. I am not deleting the table to make the FAQ true. The add-on and the country row are in the pricing table in this article.

Who should skip both tools?

Skip both when the job is a citation guarantee, because a prompt report is a sample of answers to questions you tracked, not a promise that an engine will mention you. Skip AthenaHQ's paid plan when you need a second country, the Citation Engine, or Oracle in the price you can explain, because the comparison marks those off on Starter. Skip Peec's entry plan when you already need Claude or Microsoft Copilot, because Claude is on the custom cell and I did not find Copilot on the pricing page. Skip unattended publishing on any page that states a fee. A gap export is not a published URL.

Read next:

If the model list, the credit pool, and the person who opens the cited URL are three different purchases, Book a Call and we will put the prompt, the card, and the missing URL on one page before anyone prepays a year of tracking the team will not read.

BECOME THE COMPANY AI RECOMMENDS.

Your next qualified lead starts with an answer.

Get more citations. Compete for the prompts that matter. Become the top choice in your category.

Book a Call